Is E-mail Marketing Dead or Evolving?

While looking at a few messages from the various Yahoo Groups I belong to, I found a comment from an entrepreneur who is experiencing a low open rate with an email marketing campaign.  She believed that spam might be contributing to this.   I had some other thoughts that led me to question whether or not  e-mail marketing is dead or evolving.   Here is how I responded to her message:

Hi,

I am a long time user of email campaigns and  I, too, have run into the problem of having a small percentage of recipients open my emails.   I think spam may have a lot to do with this, but here are my thoughts on what else might be happening:

  • We are in an age of information overload.   Even after you get permission from the customer, another email in their inbox can seem overwhelming.  I certainly feel this way about the many e-newsletters/email blasts I have subscribed to over the years.
  • There has been a seismic shift from advertising to the masses to focusing on niche markets. If your email reaches someone who is marginally, or even somewhat, interested in your business (we pick up a lot of these folks at trade shows and big events), you might be competing against a business that has reached this customer via a niche market.
  • As a result of niche marketing, consumers have more options to choose from to receive information that matter to them the most.  Also, advances in technology make it easier for them to retrieve information on their time.  An email showing up in their inbox at 3:00 PM may not be the time they want to hear from you.  And with so many emails going back and forth, they may forget to open yours later.
  • The sphere of influence has shifted from traditional institutions to peer-generated mediums such as Digg, Epinions, and even Ebay.  Consumers can now read real-time product reviews, comparison shop online, and get recommendations from their friends, all on their time.  They are becoming much more informed and in control of the sales process.
  • Marketing is becoming more humanized, more participatory, and much more conversational.   Monolithic forms of marketing (e-newsletters, standard websites, and e-mail auto responders) are beginning to lose their appeal.

As we enter into an emerging relationship economy where conversations are key and consumers have more options and much more control over the sales process, the successful marketer will be the one who uses two-way communication mediums (blogs, forums, and social networking sites) to communicate with their customers.

Here are three other recommendations for marketing in 2008 and in the next decade:

1.  Find a subset or niche of consumers within your target market and focus on developing a relationship with them.

2.  Enable your most enthusiastic customers to evangelize your business, and give them the tools to do so.

3. Engage your target market in conversations rather than shouting or pitching a message.

These three things can be accomplished very effectively with social media marketing.

Although I still use email campaigns to reach my customers, I have integrated the use of social technologies into an overall marketing strategy.

Business blogging is a social media marketing strategy that has worked really well for me.  Here is why:

  • I always receive great questions and comments in response to my e-mail blasts and e-newsletters, but it is hard to respond back and not everyone can see my responses.   With a blog, I can respond to questions and comments and have all of my customers see my responses. This helps to create a community around my business, which is a really important in our emerging relationship economy.
  • All of the content on my blog is indexed by search engines, so not only do I reach my client base, the potential to reach more people increases exponentially.  Why have an article that took me hours to write sit in a database when it can be indexed by search engines and work for me months and years from now?
  • My customers and readers can subscribe to my blog’s updates via email by using a RSS feed.  They can also use a feed aggregator if they are concerned about not receiving an update because of spam.

When comparing the cost of email campaigns to communicating with a blog, I think you get the best bang for your buck with using social technologies to market your business.  Bottom line:  you can reach more people and develop strong relationships along the way.

What is your opinion?  Is email marketing dead or evolving?

Want to read more about this topic?  Visit dmiracle.com for another conversation.

Related Blogs

This entry was written by Terri Holley, posted on September 3, 2008 at 4:00 pm, filed under Uncategorized and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink. Follow any comments here with the RSS feed for this post. Post a comment or leave a trackback: Trackback URL.

14 Comments

  1. Posted September 3, 2008 at 7:25 pm | Permalink

    I very much think that email is evolving. With the sudden increase in SEO and SMO strategies taking marketing budgets, integrating with email is a sure way to optimize brand awareness and promotion through an integrated communication method. I also believe that the analytics that drive email marketing is revolutionizing the targeting approach and is playing a major role in driving targeted messages. Ensuring a low spam score and trusted sender address should be enough to avoid the junk folder and short subject lines and consistent email designs combined with fresh, interesting and as mentioned, targeted content will ensure your emails definitely stay in the mind of the recipient! Email is far from dead.

  2. Posted September 3, 2008 at 7:33 pm | Permalink

    This information has come to me at a time when I have been trying to figure out why my email newsletter has been not bringing in the kind of results I had seen in the past.

    I agree that we all are bombarded by email constantly and it is very hard for me to spend the time opening all of the email I receive.

    I think that using email as a form of contact is great – marketing – no so much!

    Debbie
    Window Wear & More
    http://www.dwwam.com

  3. Posted September 3, 2008 at 10:49 pm | Permalink

    Hi Terri, 
    Interesting topic. My company as you know, has been based in large part on permission based targeted email delivery, which has worked very well for the 11+ years that HPCareer.Net has been growing and expanding.  The trend towards user participation in information delivery and evaluation is having a dramatic effect on what people “do” when they’re on-line. We are very aware of the shift to active participation in information exchange and are taking steps to integrate a more interactive platform.
    The level of sophistication of the average consumer has gone from not knowing their email address has to have an “@” sign in it, back in the mid 90′s, to reading and commenting and writing blogs on a scope unimaginable.
    How will email marketing evolve? Will we recognize it in a few years as having it’s roots in email. Will it look like Twitter? Mozilla labs is working on a project called ‘Ubiquity” http://tinyurl.com/5lf7n7 Did you know that facebook & linkedin are duking it out? http://tinyurl.com/5jamdp Consider this: http://tinyurl.com/5reovp

    Too much info to digest? No problem, (tongue in cheek) follow me! http://twitter.com/hpcareernet

  4. Posted September 3, 2008 at 11:19 pm | Permalink

    The key to increasing open rates and, by default, creating an effective campaign is to be sure that your email marketing provides something of value for the reader. Are you just selling something or do you provide information, specials, etc. that compels the recipient to actually read the message.

    Angie Segal
    ActionCOACH Business Coaching
    angiesegal@actioncoach.com

  5. Posted September 4, 2008 at 2:02 pm | Permalink

    Terri

    Excellent article! Effective marketing involves a conversation– or at least the appearance of the possibility of a back and forth exchange. Email newsletters, event the ones we willingly sign up for, often become just one more thing to delete due to time constraints.

    Lisa Jo Finstrom

  6. Posted September 4, 2008 at 2:02 pm | Permalink

    Lisa Jo Finstrom
    http://www.athomeonpurpose.com

  7. Posted September 5, 2008 at 2:09 pm | Permalink

    If email isn’t already evolving, it should be. My group coaching members keep wrestling with the best way for us to keep in touch with each other. With so many venues for connecting, overwhelm sets in. I find recently that for every few subscribers to my newsletter I get, I also have some one unsubscribing, siting TMI as the reason. This certainly presents some mind shifting challenges for those of us that use email as part of our marketing strategy.

  8. Posted September 10, 2008 at 11:50 am | Permalink

    You make sound points, Terri – thank you. Marketing feels much more appealing to me when I see it as being about conversations, relationship, two-way engagement. There’s respect for the prospective client as a creative human being, instead of a passive recipient of information. It’s the way our education systems are (hopefully) moving as well.

    http://www.youinspireme.co.uk
    helping intelligent women develop inspirational ventures

  9. Posted October 23, 2008 at 7:36 am | Permalink

    Very thoughtful discussion on the subject. It seems like only yesterdy that email marketing was a fresh new idea. The technology is changinging so fast. Email campaigns have worked very well for me and I have a faithful group of readers. I do however, want to keep up with the trends and plan to start blogging in the near future. I agree that more participatory and engaging forms of communicating will improve relationships with your target market. Only yesteday I was reading about a new type of blogging called video blogs which is very interesting to me as I am a great believer in pictures and this is the age of image and imagery. I am looking forward to working with Terri on blogging.

    http://www.kymsimage.com
    Certified image consultant. Helping individuals, companies and organizations define and refine their image, brand and style. Because image matters.
    http://www.everygirlcan.org
    Helping girls achieve a healthy & positive body image.

  10. Terri Holley
    Posted October 23, 2008 at 1:05 pm | Permalink

    These are all great and insightful comments! Thanks!

  11. Posted November 13, 2008 at 2:53 am | Permalink

    Terri,
    Thanks for your excellent presentation on blogging at the OPN last night and also for directing me to read your blog and particularly this subject. As a newby to the email marketing world, I’m open to hear what others have to say about their experience. An important point I just now realized it the timing of the delivery of the email. For me personally, I’m more apt to open and read a message that shows up either early in my day or on a Saturday or Sunday morning where I don’t feel pressured to read it, but actually have the time to read it and most likely at least give it a once over if I know the person who sent it. Otherwise, it will probably go unread and eventually be dumped. I’m looking forward to getting my blog page on my website up and running in the not too distant future, and will be looking to learning more as I go along. Thanks !!!

  12. Posted November 14, 2008 at 4:02 pm | Permalink

    Thanks, Tracy! I had a ball last night. I think more people are now understanding the power of social media. The timing of emails is very important. Thanks for mentioning this. I am more apt to open emails I receive in the morning and very late at night. You might want to create a poll on your site to ask what are the best times to receive emails that get read. I love your website and think the “Ask Tracy” feature is a great idea! Keep us informed about your blog!

  13. richard beck
    Posted May 29, 2009 at 6:05 pm | Permalink

    Hi, I went to this site and I think it is good to MAKE MONEY BY HOSTING VIDEOS, any doubt can check in the flash pie. http://www.vismomedia.com

  14. richard beck
    Posted May 29, 2009 at 11:05 pm | Permalink

    Hi, I went to this site and I think it is good to MAKE MONEY BY HOSTING VIDEOS, any doubt can check in the flash pie. http://www.vismomedia.com

One Trackback

  1. [...] Email marketing is still alive and well, but…. why share all your great content with folks just in your database? About 35% of Americans are part of a social network. Over 250,000 million people are on Facebook (20 million users update their status at least once a day).  Twitter has about 55 million monthly visitors, and in February, Neilson news reported that the use of social network usage surpassed web – based email usage. Enough said here.  There is a really good chance that a large percentage of your email subscribers are connected to an online social network. [...]

Post a Comment

Your email is never shared. Required fields are marked *

*
*
blog comments powered by Disqus

Help for Haiti: Learn What You Can Do